Skip to Content | Text-only version

College of Law :: Georgia State University

Search:

Select a quick link destination: Quick Links Law Library Current Students Criminal Justice Clinic Conflict Resolution CNCR Externships Health Law Center Metro Growth Center Pro Bono Program Tax Clinic

Offers In Compromise

An offer in compromise is an offer (usually less than the total amount due) made by a taxpayer to settle his entire outstanding tax liability.  IRC § 7122.  Generally, the amount of the offer should be equal to the taxpayer's net worth plus net disposable income for the next five years and must address all tax liability owed, including liability for tax years for which returns have not in the past been filed.  (As a condition to an acceptable offer, all returns must be filed.)   For many taxpayers who the Clinic represents, the net worth and net disposable income for the next five years are minimal, and the law prohibits the IRS from rejecting an offer simply because of the amount of the offer.  

A compromise is effective for the entire amount of outstanding assessed liability for taxes, penalties and interest.  All questions of tax liability for the year(s) or period(s) covered by such offer in compromise are conclusively settled.  Neither the taxpayer nor the government can reopen a compromised case unless there was falsification of information or documents, concealment of assets, a mutual mistake of a material fact was made that would be sufficient to set aside or reform a contract, or the taxpayer fails to meet his filing requirements for the five years following the acceptance of the offer.  Tax refunds received during the tax year following the year in which the offer is submitted are applied to the unpaid tax.

The IRS has set forth its policy for accepting an offer in compromise from a taxpayer in bankruptcy (See CC-2004-025). Although it is the position of the IRS not to accept an offer when the taxpayer is in bankruptcy, exceptions are provided.

An offer in compromise may be submitted based on the following:

1. Doubt as to liability
2. Doubt as to collectibility
3. Effective tax Administration

When an offer is submitted, financial information must be disclosed.  It is the Clinic's policy to audit all financial data presented by a client.  Whenever possible student attorneys should obtain documentary support for all data submitted with an offer. 

A taxpayer is required to file a Form 656-L, Offer in Compromise (Doubt as to Liability), when it is believed that the tax liability is incorrect, while Form 656, Offer in Compromise,  should be filed only when there is doubt as to collectibility that the tax liability could ever be paid in full, or on the basis of effective tax administration (ETA).  A taxpayer is not permitted to file offers concurrently claiming both that the tax liability is incorrect ,along with an inability to pay it. 

An offer in compromise becomes pending when it is accepted for processing.   If an offer accepted for processing does not contain sufficient information to permit the IRS to evaluate whether the offer should be accepted, the IRS will request that the taxpayer provide the needed additional information.   If the taxpayer does not submit the additional information that the IRS has requested within a reasonable time period after such a request, the IRS may return the offer to the taxpayer.  The IRS may also return an offer to compromise a tax liability if it determines that the offer was submitted solely to delay collection or was otherwise nonprocessable. An offer returned following acceptance for processing is deemed pending only for the period between the date the offer is accepted for processing and the date the IRS returns the offer to the taxpayer.

The taxpayer may withdraw an offer any time before the IRS accepts the offer.  The taxpayer must notify the IRS in writing.  The withdrawal is effective upon the IRS' receipt of the notice or upon the issuance of a letter by the IRS confirming the taxpayer's notice. 

An offer is not accepted until the IRS issues a written notification of acceptance to the taxpayer or the taxpayer's representative.  It is also not rejected until the IRS issues a written notice to the taxpayer or his representative, advising of the rejection, the reason(s) for rejection,  and the right to an appeal.  The taxpayer has 30 days from the date on the rejection letter to request an appeals conference with the Office of Appeals.  The taxpayer may not request an appeal if the offer was returned because it was nonprocessable (required tax returns not filed or taxpayer in bankruptcy proceeding), because taxpayer failed to provide requested information, or because the IRS determined that the offer to compromise was submitted solely for purposes of delay.

What is included in an offer in compromise

1. Cover letter and memorandum containing the facts and a discussion of the law.
   
   
2. Form 656 or 656-L
   
   
3. Form 433A or Form 433B (not needed if Doubt as to Liability)
   
   
4. Form 656-A (Application Fee Waiver), Application Fee Waiver Worksheet or $150 application fee
   
   
5. Supporting documents for Form 433A or B

Basis of an Offer in Compromise

Doubt as to Liability

A taxpayer may submit an offer-in-compromise based on doubt as to liability (“OIC-DATL”) if there is a genuine dispute as to the existence or amount of the correct tax liability under the law.  Treas. Reg. § 301.7122-1(b)(2).  DATL does not exist where the liability has been established by a final court decision or judgment concerning the existence or amount of the liability.  The IRS may not reject an OIC-DATL because it could not find its administrative file.

The taxpayer must submit a detailed written statement explaining why she does not owe the tax along with Form 656-L.  A financial statement (Form 433) does not need to be included with an offer made on the basis of DATL.

Section 6330(c)(2)(B) allows a taxpayer to challenge the existence or amount of his underlying tax liability if he neither received a notice of deficiency nor otherwise had an opportunity to dispute it.

A challenge to the amount of the tax liability made in the form of an OIC-DATL by a taxpayer who has received a notice of deficiency is a challenge to the underlying tax liability. Because the taxpayer had his or her chance to challenge that liability, section 6330(c)(2)(B) bars them from challenging it again.

Similarly, an OIC-DATL will be rejected where the underlying tax liability was previously stipulated in a Tax Court decision. In this situation also the tax liability can't validly be considered a "doubtful liability" under the applicable regulation. Sec. 301.7122-1(b)(1); Oyer v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2003-178, affd. 97 Fed. Appx. 68 (8th Cir. 2004).

Doubt as to Collectibility

A taxpayer may submit an offer based on doubt as to collectibility ("OIC-DATC") if he or she believes that he or she cannot ever pay the full amount of the tax owed.  Treas. Reg. § 301.7122-1(b)(3).  DATC exists in any case where the taxpayer's assets and income are less than the full amount of the liability.  The taxpayer must submit Form 433-A or 433-B showing his or her current financial situation.

A determination of doubt as to collectability will include a determination of ability to pay. In determining ability to pay, the Secretary will permit taxpayers to retain sufficient funds to pay basic living expenses (see Collection Financial Standards).  The determination of the amount of such basic living expenses will be founded upon an evaluation of the individual facts and circumstances presented by the taxpayer's case. To guide this determination, guidelines published by the Secretary on national and local living expense standards will be taken into account.

Where a taxpayer is offering to compromise a liability for which the taxpayer's spouse has no liability, the assets and income of the non-liable spouse will not be considered in determining the amount of an adequate offer. The assets and income of a non-liable spouse may be considered, however, to the extent property has been transferred by the taxpayer to the non-liable spouse under circumstances that would permit the IRS to effect collection of the taxpayer's liability from such property (e.g., property that was conveyed in fraud of creditors), property has been transferred by the taxpayer to the non-liable spouse for the purpose of removing the property from consideration by the IRS in evaluating the compromise.

Where collection of the taxpayer's liability from the assets and income of the non-liable spouse is permitted by applicable state law (e.g., under state community property laws), the assets and income of the non-liable spouse will be considered in determining the amount of an adequate offer except to the extent that the taxpayer and the non-liable spouse demonstrate that collection of such assets and income would have a material and adverse impact on the standard of living of the taxpayer, the non-liable spouse, and their dependents.

The IRS has provided Standards for use in deterining whether there is doubt as to collectability.

• National Standards have been established for five necessary expenses: food, housekeeping supplies,
  apparel and services, personal care products and services, and miscellaneous.
• National Standards have been established out-of-pocket health care expenses including medical services, prescription drugs, and medical supplies (e.g. eyeglasses, contact lenses, etc.).  The out-of-pocket health care standard amount is allowed in addition to the amount taxpayers pay for health insurance.
• Local Standards have been established for Housing and Utilities.  The housing and utilities standards are derived from Census and BLS data, and are provided by state down to the county level.  The standard for a particular county and family size includes both housing and utilities allowed for a taxpayer’s primary place of residence. Housing and Utilities standards include mortgage or rent, property taxes, interest, insurance, maintenance, repairs, gas, electric, water, heating oil, garbage collection, telephone and cell phone.
• Local Standards have been established for Transportation. The transportation standards for taxpayers with a vehicle consist of two parts:   nationwide figures for monthly loan or lease payments referred to as ownership costs, and additional amounts for monthly operating costs broken down by Census Region and Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA).   A conversion chart has been provided with the standards that lists the states that comprise each Census Region, as well as the counties and cities included in each MSA.  The ownership cost portion of the transportation standard, although it applies nationwide, is still considered part of the Local Standards

Effective Tax Administration

Even though a taxpayer is able to pay the tax, a compromise may be entered to promote effective tax administration ("ETA") when:

1. Collection of the full liability would cause the taxpayer economic hardship or
2. Compelling public policy or equity considerations identified by the taxpayer provide a sufficient basis for compromising the liability, and
3. Compromise of the liability will not undermine compliance by taxpayers with the tax laws [Treas. Reg.
   § 301.7122-1(b)(4)]

Economic hardship is defined as the inability to pay reasonable basic living expenses.  Treas. Reg. § 301.6343-1.  In determining reasonable basic living expenses, the IRS is to consider relevant information such as the taxpayer's age, employment status and history, number of dependents, and other exceptional circumstances.  Factors to support a finding of economic hardship include, but are not limited to the following:

1. Taxpayer is incapable of earning a living because of a long term illness, medical condition, or disability, and it is reasonably foreseeable that taxpayer's financial resources will be exhausted providing for care and support during the course of the condition;
2. Although taxpayer has certain monthly income, that income is exhausted each month in providing for the care of dependents with no other means of support; and
3. Although taxpayer has certain assets, the taxpayer is unable to borrow against the equity in those assets and liquidation of those assets to pay outstanding tax liabilities would render the taxpayer unable to meet basic living expenses.

Compromise based on equity and public policy will only be accepted if, due to exceptional circumstances, collection of the full liability would undermine public confidence that the tax laws are being administered in a fair and equitable manner.  The circumstances must be such that compromise is justified even though a similarly situated taxpayer may have paid his liability in full.

Rules and Requirements For All Offers

1. All required federal tax returns must be filed
2. Not currently involved with a pending bankruptcy proceeding
3. Form 656 or 656-L
4. Form 433-A or 433-B (not needed if doubt as to liability) accompanies Form 656.  This form requires a substantial amount of supporting documents.  See Documents to Support Form 433.
5. Form 656-A (Application Fee Waiver), Application Fee Waiver worksheet, or $150 application fee.
6. Written detailed narrative as to the facts and circumstances of the taxpayer explaining why offer should be accepted.

Payment Terms

 

Consequences of an Offer

1. The taxpayer must file all required Federal tax returns and pay all required taxes for the next five years or until the offer amount is paid in full, whichever is longer.  Otherwise, the offer will go into default, and the full amount of the original liability (less any amounts paid pursuant to the offer) with interest will be reinstated.
   
   
2. The statute of limitations for the assessment of tax liability for the tax periods compromised is suspended.
   
   
3. The IRS will keep all payments and credits made, received or applied to the total original tax liability before the submission of this offer.
   
   
4. The IRS will keep any refund, including interest, the taxpayer is entitled to for the tax year the offer was accepted and the refund for the following tax year.
   
   
5. Once the IRS accepts the offer, the taxpayer cannot dispute the amount of tax liability in court or otherwise.
   
   
6. If the taxpayer should default on an accepted offer, then the IRS may also:
   1. Immediately file suit to collect the entire unpaid balance of the offer
   2. Immediately file suit to collect an amount equal to the original amount of the tax liability as liquidating damages
   3. File suit or levy to collect the original amount of the tax liability without further notice of any kind
      
      
7. The IRS may not levy against the property or rights to property of a taxpayer to collect the liability that is the subject of the offer during the period the offer is pending, for 30 days immediately following the rejection of the offer, and for any period when a timely filed appeal from the rejection is being considered by Appeals.
   
   
8. The statute of limitation on collection is suspended while an offer is pending.

Compromise of a Compromise

If the taxpayer is unable to pay the balance of an accepted offer, the IRS has the option to: (1) temporarily adjust the terms of the offer, (2) formally compromise the existing compromise or (3) exercise the default provisions of the offer.  The Internal Revenue Code authorizes the Commissioner under § 7122 to accept an offer in compromise of an accepted offer.  The new offer to compromise the original offer must be based on doubt as to collectibility.

The taxpayer must send  a current financial statement (Form 433-A or 433-B) and a written proposal of the new offer in letter format to the office where the original offer was submitted. The letter should be addressed to the Commissioner of the Internal Revenue Service and include the following information:

1. Name, address and Social Security number or the taxpayer identification number of the taxpayer
2. Amount proposed and the terms of the payment
3. Acceptance date of the original offer
4. Waiver of any and all claims to amounts due from the United States up to the time of acceptance to the extent of the difference between the amount offered and the amount of the claim covered by the offer and
5. Reasons why request is being made to compromise the existing agreement

The compliance agreement (item 8 on Form 656) will remain in effect from the date the original offer was accepted.

Potential Default Cases

An offer can reach a potential default status in one of two ways:  the taxpayer failed to make timely payments of the amount due based on the terms of the offer or a related collateral agreement, or the taxpayer has not adhered to the compliance provisions of the offer contract.  The revenue officer has the discretion to grant up to a six-month extension if the taxpayer can pay the defaulted amount in 6 months or less.

Resources

The LITP Newsletter - Allowable expenses

Collection Financial Standards

Offer In Compromise To-Do List

Application Fee Waiver

Sample letter requesting documents to support offer

Supporting document checklist 

Statement Supporting OIC (include as attachment to Form 656)

Internal Revenue Code

IRC § 7122

Compromises

Treasury Regulations

Treas. Reg. § 301.6343-1(b)(4)	Economic Hardship (4/02)
Treas. Reg. § 301.7122-1	Compromises (only old temporary regulations are available online at this time)

Internal Revenue Manual

Part 5  Chapter 8	Collecting Process: Offers in Compromise
Part 8  Chapter 13	Closing Agreement Manual: Offers in Compromise

IRS Forms and Publications

IR-2007-50, March 07	IRS Revises Offer in Compromise Application Form
FS-2007-16, March 07	Revisions to Form 656, Offer in Compromise
IRS Form 433-A	Collection Information Statement for Wage Earners and Self-Employed Individuals (Fill-in)
IRS Form 433-B	Collection Information Statement for Businesses (Fill-in)
IRS Form 656	Offer in Compromise Package
IRS Form 656-L	Offer in Compromise (Doubt as to Liability application)
IRS Publication 594	The IRS Collection Process
IRS Publication 1854	How to Prepare a Collection Information Statement